A Cascade County District Judge has denied the appeal of a Red Lodge man convicted in 2010 of 38 counts of illegal outfitting on the Missouri River.
The ruling may bring to a close a case that started in 2005 and led to a tougher law adopted by the 2009 Montana Legislature that makes outfitting without a license a felony.
District Court Judge Kenneth Neill last month denied 51-year-old John Kebble’s appeal of his July 2010 conviction.
Fish, Wildlife & Parks Region 4 game wardens brought the charges in 2007 against Kebble following numerous tips from legal outfitters about his fishing clients on the blue ribbon trout section of the Missouri River downstream of Holter Dam.
Because Kebble was not a licensed outfitter, game wardens began an investigation that culminated in a case that indicated Kebble guided 38 groups of anglers and made more than $120,000 for the 2005 and 2006 fishing seasons, which amounted to about six months work.
After a four-day jury trial, Justice of the Peace Kathleen Jensen sentenced Kebble to 36 days in jail and a fine of $12,730.
At the time, Kebble could only be cited for misdemeanors. However, outrage over the case led the 2009 Legislature to put a bigger bite into the law.
In his appeal, Kebble’s attorney, Jack Morris of Helena, challenged the conviction on five issues: Justice Court failed to record pretrial hearings, Justice Court improperly granted a state motion relating to a previous conviction, Justice Court erred in not removing a juror, a mistrial should have been declared for the state’s failure to provide evidence during pretrial discovery, and Justice Court improperly sentenced Kebble under statutes in effect at the time of the offenses.
Neill denied the appeal writing, “Justice Court did not err and Kebble’s sentence should not be reversed.”
When notified of Neill’s ruling, Jim Kropp, FWP Chief of Law Enforcement, said, “This case affirms our commitment to protect the state’s fish and wildlife resources, like the Missouri River, for all of our constituents.”